I recently had an interesting talk with a reader about which speaker to bring backpacking. This chat just happened to be in a public forum, and a heated debate rapidly erupted. Long story short, this sounded like an excellent topic for an article, so let’s talk about music in the backcountry.
First, it’s fair to say that there are two sides of this debate, so I wanted to cover them both in as much detail as possible while still staying fairly objective.
Of course, there are those who love to play music in the backcountry. Music is an amazing phenomenon. It doesn’t hurt that portable speakers are now everywhere, either. The quality of portable audio devices has become quite good, while managing to keep them compact and easy to carry. With the vast adoption of smart phones, a source of music is always just a couple presses away, so it makes sense that this would trickle into the woods. Rocking out to your favorite song at the camp fire or drifting off while listening to a musical score is a great way to unwind, entertain, and keep the evening lively, especially on long winter nights. And, one can be argued, that listening to music is not just enjoyable, but a right to humans everywhere. It’s also worth noting that playing music in bear country, especially while so, is a great way to announce your presence to avoid walking up on an unsuspecting critter, the purpose of a bear bell. To this group, music is a delight, uplifting, energizing, and full of life and emotion, welcomed on any trail.
Now, the other side of the argument is for pure, blissful silence in the wilderness. Many people go camping as a means to get away from the ever pumping iron heart of city life, and hearing someone else’s music is simply a reminder of the never ending noise and commotion of the environment they’re trying to escape. For those, the sounds of birds, coyotes and the wind rustling miles of rhododendron is enough of a musical score to provide all the rhythm one needs to be lulled off to sleep at night. To this group, hearing the music of another is disruptive, irritating, and even maddening to the point that many campers have packed up and left an area to avoid the sound of others, or even approached other camps with their thoughts. According to a quick poll on the Backpacker forums, almost everyone there fell into this group, although there is probably a certain bias for solitude there. More on that later. It’s also been pointed out that if you’re listening to music while camping, you’re unaware of your surroundings and could potential be opening yourself up to dangerous situations, be that incoming weather, animals or otherwise.
part of the conflict here comes from the fact that you cannot, and will not always be aware of the desires, or even presence, of those camping around you. In the wilderness, you can be camping twenty meters from another group of quiet campers and never be aware of it. This has happened to me many times as I slipped off the find the restroom on a “deserted” mountain during poor weather conditions. The problem is somewhat elevated by the fact that, in the wild, the sound of music can carry for miles against the otherwise quiet landscape, reflecting and even amplifying off valleys and walls in ways that aren’t predictable. While everyone at your camp may be fine with music, there like is another individual of group within ear shot that wants noting to do with you, your group, or your music. I recall several instances where I could hear music from across sprawling lakes, and even canyons with huge swallows of space in between us. Although, my ears are particular sensitive to subtle sounds in the distance.
Now, there is a happy medium to this situation that’s often suggested by long time backpackers – Headphones. Headphones provide audio quality far surpassing that of portable speakers, and they’re subtle. They’re also light weight, affordable, and allow music to be played as loud as one wants without the risk of disturbing others. I normally pack a pair of headphones with my on my trips. Although they’re rarely used as I would much rather soak up the soundscape of the natural world around me, I like having the option to jam out if I’m having trouble sleeping or need help passing the time during a storm.
So, what do you guys think. Where do you fall in this new age debate of sound vs silence? I’d be quite interesting to hear the thoughts of my readers as I imagine the demographic here is a bit different than that of the forums. Let me know what you think.
Thanks as always for reading! Don’t forget to follow our blog for future updates and reviews, and maybe consider liking this post. It helps me out a lot. If you have any questions, comment below, send us an email, or find us on Twitter or Facebook (links on the right).